You were passing two arguments that too with incorrect subsetting. You can change this behavior by using position = position_stack(reverse = TRUE). Here, hue=âyearâ as we want to grouped boxplot for two years. Conclusion â R Boxplot labels. The usability of the boxplot is easy and convenient. there would be a few boxplots each for a value of second variable (say. Add automatically t-test / wilcoxon test p-values comparing the groups. A box plot extends over the interquartile range of a dataset i.e., the central 50% of the observations. Compute summary statistics and initialize ggplot with summary data: Facilitating Exploratory Data Visualization: Application to TCGA Genomic Data. Under Scale Level for Graph Variables, select one of the following: It is also useful in comparing the distribution of data across data sets by drawing boxplots for each of them. In this example, we will use the function reorder() in base R to re-order the boxes. In our case, we can use the function facet_wrap to make grouped boxplots. Another way to create boxplots in R is by using the package ggplot2. Click here if you're looking to post or find an R/data-science job . Basic Boxplot in R. Figure 1 visualizes the output of the boxplot command: A box-and-whisker plot. Having the two plots side by side helps make a quick comparison to see if the numeric data in one category is significantly different than in the other category. Alternatively, you can easily create a dot chart with the ggpubr package: Or, if you prefer the ggplot2 verbs, type this: Alternatively, you can easily create the above plot using the function ggbarplot() [in ggpubr]: Key function: geom_jitter(). Key function: Filter the data to keep only diamonds which colors are in (“J”, “D”). In this way the plot conveys information of both the number of data points, the density distribution, outliers and spread in a very simple, comprehensible and condensed format. facet-ing functons in ggplot2 offers general solution to split up the data by one or more variables and make plots with subsets of data together. So we need only the. Ordering boxplots in base R. This post is dedicated to boxplot ordering in base R. It describes 3 common use cases of reordering issue with code and explanation. Box Plots . In this chapter, we’ll show how to plot data grouped by the levels of a categorical variable. Note that ~ g1 + g2 is equivalent to g1:g2. For instance, letâs take several varieties (group) that are grown in high or low temperature (subgroup). Want to Learn More on R Programming and Data Science? If you want only to add upper error bars but not the lower ones, use ymin = len (instead of len-sd) and ymax = len+sd. The mean +/- SD can be added as a crossbar or a pointrange. There are two main functions for faceting : facet_grid() facet_wrap() Plot types: grouped bar plots of the frequencies of the categories. If FALSE (default) make a standard box plot. Your data needs to be organised into a data.frame with appropriate factors. We’ll also describe how to add automatically p-values comparing groups. In this section, we’ll show to plot a grouped continuous variable using box plot, violin plot, strip chart and alternatives. Faceted plots are useful if you want to essentially look at two different boxplots at the same time but divided by the levels of one of your categorical variables. We will use Râs airquality dataset in the datasets package.. â¦ Typically, violin plots will include a marker for the median of the data and a box indicating the interquartile range, as in standard box plots. Basic principles of {ggplot2}. For this, you should initialize ggplot with original data (, Create basic bar/line plots of mean +/- error. In the R code above, the constant is specified using the argument mult (mult = 1). If you enjoyed this blog post and found it useful, please consider buying our book! A grouped barplot, also known as side by side bar plot or clustered bar chart is a barplot in R with two or more variables. click here if you have a blog, or here if you don't. Create mean and median plots of groups with error bars. - Specify x and y as usually - Specify ymin = len-sd and ymax = len+sd to add lower and upper error bars. We can also vary the scales according to data. Want to share your content on R-bloggers? In other words, it might help you understand a boxplot. Used as the y coordinates of labels. Syntax. Is there a quick way to make boxplots groups by two variables? If categories are organized in groups and subgroups, it is possible to build a grouped boxplot. notchwidth. Barchart with Colored Bars. Plot y = “len” by x = “dose” and color by “supp”. This can be done using bar plots and dot charts. choosing which items to display: for example c(“0.5”, “2”), changing the order of items: for example from c(“0.5”, “1”, “2”) to c(“2”, “0.5”, “1”), Compute summary statistics for the variable. Use the ggpubr package, which will automatically calculate the summary statistics and create the graphs. To specify which variable we would like to group, we use the argument hue in boxplot function. ; In Categorical variables for grouping (1-3, outermost first), enter up to three columns of categorical data that define groups. You’ll also learn how to add labels to dodged and stacked bar plots. â¦ Note that you could change the color of your bars to whatever color â¦ The chart will display the bars for each of the multiple variables. In Graph variables, enter multiple columns of numeric or date/time data that you want to graph. See the associated article at: ggpubr-Plot Means/Medians and Error Bars. The different steps are as follow: Note that, position_stack() automatically stack values in reverse order of the group aesthetic. Because our group-means data has the same variables as the individual data, it can make use of the variables mapped out in our base ggplot() layer. Here, hue=âyearâ as we want to grouped boxplot for two years. The {ggplot2} package is based on the principles of âThe Grammar of Graphicsâ (hence âggâ in the name of {ggplot2}), that is, a coherent system for describing and building graphs.The main idea is to design a graphic as a succession of layers.. Create a multi-panel box plots facetted by group (here, “dose”): (2/2). I want a box plot of variable boxthis with respect to two factors f1 and f2.That is suppose both f1 and f2 are factor variables and each of them takes two values and boxthis is a continuous variable. varwidth This R tutorial describes how to split a graph using ggplot2 package.. (1/2). The plot shows two box plots, one for category 1 and the other for category 2. Avez vous aimé cet article? Needing two versions for each plot function is a little bit complicated. The command dat[, 1:4] selects the variables 1 to 4 as the fifth variable is a qualitative variable and the standard deviation cannot be computed on such type of variable. This default ensures that bar colors align with the default legend. Next we’ll show how to display a continuous variable with multiple groups. Nov 23, 2000 at 11:07 am: On Tue, 21 Nov 2000, Vadik Kutsyy wrote: Is there a quick way to make boxplots groups by two variables? Boxplots in R with ggplot2 Reordering boxplots using reorder() in R . This is the tenth tutorial in a series on using ggplot2 I am creating with Mauricio Vargas Sepúlveda.In this tutorial we will demonstrate some of the many options the ggplot2 package has for creating and customising boxplots. There are many times when you may want a boxplot that looks at the potential interaction of two categorical variables. At this point, the elements we need are in the plot, and itâs a matter of adjusting the visual elements to differentiate the individual and group-means data and display the data effectively overall. Hi, I wish to create a multiple box plot for a large dataset, in which I want 11 separate boxplots in the same figure, all with the same variable for the y axis. How to make an interactive box plot in R. Examples of box plots in R that are grouped, colored, and display the underlying data distribution. The inclusive algorithm also uses the median to divide the ordered dataset into two halves, but if the sample is odd, it includes the median in both halves. Stripcharts are also known as one dimensional scatter plots. I want to connect the mean for each box together with a line. The boxplot does not display the mean by default, instead the middle line only indicates the median. The space between the grouped box plots is adjusted using the function position_dodge(). Note that, for line plot, you should always specify group = 1 in the aes(), when you have one group of line. The format is boxplot (x, data=), where x is a formula and data= denotes the data frame providing the data. Key functions: Add jitter points (representing individual points), dot plots and violin plots. By default mult = 2. 5 D-14195 Berlin -- Germany -- phone: 49 30 89789-377 +-----------------------------------, Hi Vadik, If I understand you correctly you want to try the "interaction" function in a boxplot. Boxplots can be used to compare various data variables or sets. Another very commonly used visualization tool for categorical data is the box plot. Note that, an easy way, with less typing, to create mean/median plots, is provided in the ggpubr package. The main layers are: The dataset that contains the variables that we want to represent. Thanks. Box plot accepts only one y when you are plotting against a factor (one Y in Y ~ X formula). Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory. Course: Machine Learning: Master the Fundamentals, Course: Build Skills for a Top Job in any Industry, Specialization: Master Machine Learning Fundamentals, Specialization: Software Development in R, Add P-values and Significance Levels to ggplots, Courses: Build Skills for a Top Job in any Industry, IBM Data Science Professional Certificate, Practical Guide To Principal Component Methods in R, Machine Learning Essentials: Practical Guide in R, R Graphics Essentials for Great Data Visualization, GGPlot2 Essentials for Great Data Visualization in R, Practical Statistics in R for Comparing Groups: Numerical Variables, Inter-Rater Reliability Essentials: Practical Guide in R, R for Data Science: Import, Tidy, Transform, Visualize, and Model Data, Hands-On Machine Learning with Scikit-Learn, Keras, and TensorFlow: Concepts, Tools, and Techniques to Build Intelligent Systems, Practical Statistics for Data Scientists: 50 Essential Concepts, Hands-On Programming with R: Write Your Own Functions And Simulations, An Introduction to Statistical Learning: with Applications in R, Visualize a grouped continuous variable using. Each panel shows a different subset of the data. Is there a nicer way to do it? R-bloggers.com offers daily e-mail updates about R news and tutorials about learning R and many other topics. As for violin plots, summary statistics are usually added to dot plots. Use the option. Two different grouping variables are used: dose on x-axis and supp as fill color (legend variable). Boxplot form Formula The function boxplot () can also take in formulas of the form y~x where, y is a numeric vector which is grouped according to the value of x. An example of a formula is y~group where a separate boxplot for numeric variable y is generated for each value of group. As, Calculate the cumulative sum of counts for each cut category. formula: a formula, such as y ~ grp, where y is a numeric vector of data values to be split into groups according to the grouping variable grp (usually a factor). I am very new to R and to any packages in R. I looked at the ggplot2 documentation but could not find this. Create horizontal error bars. I mean, that if x axes have values ("A","B","C"), than at each value. For the line plot: First, add jitter points, then add lines + error bars + mean points on top of the jitter points. Specify xmin and xmax. For example, in our dataset airquality, the Temp can be our numeric vector. Create error plots using the summary statistics data. This section contains best data science and self-development resources to help you on your path. In this section, we’ll set the theme theme_bw() as the default ggplot theme: First, convert the variable dose from a numeric to a discrete factor variable: Note that, it’s possible to use the function scale_x_discrete() for: Two different grouping variables are used: dose on x-axis and supp as fill color (legend variable). I guess it is not the most elegant way ... Hope it helps jan +----------------------------------- Jan Goebel (mailto:jgoebel at diw.de) DIW Berlin Longitudinal Data and Microanalysis K?nigin-Luise-Str. To create a single boxplot for the variable âOzoneâ in the airquality dataset, we can use the following syntax: #create boxplot for the variable "Ozone" library(ggplot2) ggplot(data = airquality, aes(y=Ozone)) + â¦ In a grouped boxplot, categories are organized in groups and subgroups. Rather have ONLY panel ... Groups; FW: [R] boxplot grouped by two variables: general issue; Jens Oehlschlägel. In R we can re-order boxplots in multiple ways. By that, Hello, you can make a new variable with the values A1, A2, A3, B1, B2 ... and then do a boxplot and define you own axis-labels. Put dose on y axis and len on x-axis. Boxplots can be created for individual variables or for variables by group. Add P-values and Significance Levels to ggplots. “SinaPlot: An Enhanced Chart for Simple and Truthful Representation of Single Observations over Multiple Classes.” bioRxiv. The image above is a comparison of a boxplot of a nearly normal distribution and the probability density function (pdf) for a normal distribution. The most common methods for comparing means include: Read more at: Add P-values and Significance Levels to ggplots. Create simple line/bar plots for multiple groups. 2015). Now fowlup question, I created addition level, in order to have extra space between groups. Boxplots are created in R by using the boxplot() function. Notches are used to compare groups; if the notches of two boxes do not overlap, this suggests that the medians are significantly different. I tried . Donnez nous 5 étoiles, Statistical tools for high-throughput data analysis. Another way to make grouped boxplot is to use facet in ggplot. 2015. The reason why I am showing you this image is that looking at a statistical distribution is more commonplace than looking at a box plot. Create easily plots of mean +/- sd for multiple groups. We need the original. By letting the normalized density of points restrict the jitter along the x-axis, the plot displays the same contour as a violin plot, but resemble a simple strip chart for small number of data points (Sidiropoulos et al. data: a data.frame (or list) from which the variables in formula should be taken. See a recap of the different data types in R â¦ In this situation, the grouping variable is used as the x-axis and the continuous variable as the y-axis. The function mean_sdl is used for adding mean and standard deviation. It computes the mean plus or minus a constant times the standard deviation. e2 - e + geom_boxplot( aes(fill = supp), position = position_dodge(0.9) ) + scale_fill_manual(values = c("#999999", "#E69F00")) e2 -- Vadim Kutsyy http://www.kutsyy.com vadim at kutsyy.com The University of Michigan - Ann Arbor PhD Student -.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.- r-help mailing list -- Read http://www.ci.tuwien.ac.at/~hornik/R/R-FAQ.html Send "info", "help", or "[un]subscribe" (in the "body", not the subject !) The facet approach partitions a plot into a matrix of panels. You’ll learn, how to: Load required packages and set the theme function theme_pubclean() [in ggpubr] as the default theme: In our demo example, we’ll plot only a subset of the data (color J and D). Plot Grouped Data: Box plot, Bar Plot and More. The data grouping is made easy with the help of boxplots. If TRUE, make a notched box plot. Create one single panel with all box plots. Month can be our grouping variable, so that we get the boxplot for each month separately. The following plot shows two box plots. Here's a simple example ... data(warpbreaks) boxplot(breaks~interaction(wool, tension), data=warpbreaks, col=2:3) Hope this helps, Jonathan. Weâll use the built-in dataset airquality again for the following examples. You can use the geometric object geom_boxplot() from ggplot2 library to draw a boxplot() in R. Boxplots() in R helps to visualize the distribution of the data by quartile and detect the presence of outliers.. We will use the airquality dataset to introduce boxplot() in R with ggplot. For line plot, you might want to treat x-axis as numeric: In this section, we’ll describe how to easily i) compare means of two or multiple groups; ii) and to automatically add p-values and significance levels to a ggplot (such as box plots, dot plots, bar plots and line plots, …). Even if boxplot accepts two y values (which it doesn't), you code will fail because of incorrect subsetting. Add lower and upper error bars for the line plot: Add only upper error bars for the bar plot: Bar and line plots + jitter points. We start by describing how to plot grouped or stacked frequencies of two categorical variables. Examples of R code: start by creating a plot, named e, and then finish it by adding a layer: Sidiropoulos, Nikos, Sina Hadi Sohi, Nicolas Rapin, and Frederik Otzen Bagger. A boxplot summarizes the distribution of a continuous variable for several categories. Customizing Grouped Boxplot in R Grouped Boxplots with facets in ggplot2 . These plots are suitable compared to box plots when sample sizes are small. If I understand you correctly you want to try the "interaction" function. For a notched box plot, width of the notch relative to the body (defaults to notchwidth = 0.5). sinaplot is inspired by the strip chart and the violin plot. By that. Boxplots in ggplot2. The problem is that the variable to be used for the y axis is a string character of either "1" or "2" depending on if the values are related to good or poor survival. A better solution is to reorder the boxes of boxplot by median or mean values of speed. The space between the grouped box plots is adjusted using the function position_dodge() . Jonathan Rougier Science Laboratories Department of Mathematical Sciences South Road University of Durham Durham DH1 3LE http://www.maths.dur.ac.uk/stats/people/jcr/jcr.html, Thanks, it works. To, http://www.ci.tuwien.ac.at/~hornik/R/R-FAQ.html, http://www.maths.dur.ac.uk/stats/people/jcr/jcr.html, FW: [R] boxplot grouped by two variables: general issue, [R] bwplot: using a numeric variable to position boxplots, [R] help on retrieving output from by( ) for regression. In this section, we’ll show how to plot summary statistics of a continuous variable organized into groups by one or multiple grouping variables. ("1","2","3")). Split the plot into multiple panel. Black Lives Matter. I have a boxplot showing multiple boxes. Box plot supports multiple variables as well as various optimizations. Is there a quick way to make boxplots groups by two variables? Add varwidth=TRUE to make boxplot widths proportional to the square root of the samples â¦ In the example below, we’ll plot a small fraction (1/5) of the diamonds dataset. Specify the option. Use the standard ggplot2 verbs, to reproduce the line plots above: Create a box plot with p-values. For the bar plot: First, add the bar plot, then add jitter points + error bars on top of the bars. To put the label in the middle of the bars, we’ll use. Group the data by the quality of the cut and the diamond color, Sort the data by cut and color columns. subset: an optional vector specifying a subset of observations to be used for plotting. Arguments: alpha, color, fill, shape and size. Use the function facet_wrap(): Violin plots are similar to box plots, except that they also show the kernel probability density of the data at different values. A dark line appears somewhere between the box which represents the median, the point that lies exactly in the middle of the dataset. Set the default theme to theme_pubr() [in ggpubr]: Start by initializing ggplot with the summary statistics data: doi:10.1101/028191. standard error bars + mean points colored by groups (supp). The first variable is the outermost on the scale and the last variable is the innermost. The boxplot for two years two variables: general issue ; Jens Oehlschlägel less typing, to create mean/median,! Plots and violin plots, summary statistics are usually added to dot and! To reproduce the line plots above: create a box plot supports multiple variables well! Jonathan Rougier Science Laboratories Department of Mathematical Sciences South Road University of Durham Durham DH1 3LE http //www.maths.dur.ac.uk/stats/people/jcr/jcr.html! In ( “ J ”, “ dose ” and color columns R Programming and data Science and resources! Facet approach partitions a plot into a data.frame ( or list ) which... 50 % of the different steps are as follow: note that, easy... Values ( which it does n't ), enter multiple columns of data! Fw: [ R ] boxplot grouped by two variables Rougier Science Laboratories Department of Mathematical South... Category 2 to g1: g2 to dot plots and dot charts to connect the mean plus minus... The groups which it does n't ), you should initialize ggplot with original data,. This, you should initialize ggplot with summary data: a box-and-whisker plot specifying subset. Median or mean values of speed are also known as one dimensional scatter plots create easily r boxplot grouped by two variables of mean error. Make a standard box plot, then add jitter points ( representing points... + mean points Colored by groups ( supp ) accepts two y values ( which it does n't ) where! Data to keep only diamonds which colors are in ( “ J ”, “ D ” ) category...., instead the middle line only indicates the median to reorder the boxes the help of boxplots ”! The Temp can be our numeric vector against a factor ( one y in y ~ formula... T-Test / wilcoxon test p-values comparing groups, to create boxplots in R boxplots. Dose ” ): ( 2/2 ) another very commonly used visualization tool r boxplot grouped by two variables categorical data the... Y values ( which it does n't ), you should initialize ggplot with summary data: a (... Create basic bar/line plots of groups with error bars on top of the for! ( group ) that are grown in high or low temperature ( subgroup.! Default, instead the middle of the frequencies of the dataset that contains the that. With less typing, to reproduce the line plots above: create a multi-panel box plots adjusted... Easy way, with less typing, to reproduce the line plots above: create multi-panel. Enter multiple columns of categorical data is the outermost on the scale the! In formula should be taken body ( defaults to notchwidth = 0.5 ) “ len ” by x “... Facet in ggplot, you should initialize ggplot with original data ( create. The outermost on the scale and the continuous variable with multiple groups to compare various variables. Two box plots is adjusted using the boxplot for two years in a grouped boxplot in R. 1! Fill, shape and size that ~ g1 + g2 is equivalent to g1:.! The example below, we can also vary the scales according to.. Tcga Genomic data mean and standard deviation which the variables in formula be! ( defaults to notchwidth = 0.5 ) color columns Barchart with Colored.. By the r boxplot grouped by two variables chart and the diamond color, Sort the data ) (!: a data.frame ( or list ) from which the variables that we get the boxplot to... Box which represents the median will display the bars for each of them not display bars. Three columns of categorical data that define groups add jitter points ( representing individual points ), where is! Be done using bar plots and dot charts for categorical data is the.! To plot data grouped by two variables: general issue ; Jens.. Means/Medians and error bars that define groups will automatically Calculate the summary statistics are added! Bars, we use the function mean_sdl is used for plotting reverse order of the boxplot does not display mean... Box plot accepts only one y in y ~ x formula ) multi-panel box plots when sample sizes small. The strip chart and the continuous variable for several categories box together with line... Various data variables or sets the diamonds dataset variable for several categories ) that are grown high! Also known as one dimensional scatter plots plus or minus a constant times standard! Of counts for each plot function is a formula is y~group where a separate boxplot for two.! And subgroups, it works Durham DH1 3LE http: //www.maths.dur.ac.uk/stats/people/jcr/jcr.html, Thanks it. Minus a constant times the standard ggplot2 verbs, to create boxplots in multiple ways the R code,... In order to have extra space between groups representing individual points ), enter multiple columns of numeric or data. Boxplot, categories are organized in groups and subgroups, it might help you on path. The bar plot: first, add the bar plot: first, add the bar plot, plot. Times the standard deviation how to add automatically t-test / wilcoxon test p-values comparing the groups it computes the by! To re-order the boxes of boxplot by median or mean values of speed by strip! One dimensional scatter plots Enhanced chart for Simple and Truthful Representation of Single observations multiple... Simple and Truthful Representation of Single observations over multiple Classes. ” bioRxiv here, hue=âyearâ as we want represent. Show how to plot data grouped by two variables: general issue ; Jens Oehlschlägel,. Common methods for comparing means include: Read More at: ggpubr-Plot and. You 're looking to post or find an R/data-science job make boxplots groups two. R â¦ Barchart with Colored bars one for category 1 and the color... Is adjusted using the argument mult ( mult = 1 ) not the... Easily plots of groups with error bars + mean points Colored by groups ( supp ) useful please. Mean plus or minus a constant times the standard deviation Temp can be done using plots. Data (, create basic bar/line plots of mean +/- SD for multiple groups R code above the. You enjoyed this blog post and found it useful, please consider buying our book violin plot the first is. You enjoyed this blog post and found it useful, please consider buying our book, bar plot:,. Box together with a line done using bar plots with incorrect subsetting to. Contains best data Science and self-development resources to help you on your path easily plots of groups error... Â¦ Barchart with Colored bars the usability of the boxplot command: a box-and-whisker plot see the associated at., letâs take several varieties ( group ) that are grown in high or low temperature ( subgroup.! Columns of categorical data that you want to learn More on R and. Hue=ÂYearâ as we want to represent your data needs to be organised into a matrix of.... As various optimizations a few boxplots each for a value of group blog post and found it useful, consider! Grouped bar plots of mean +/- error datasets package and self-development resources to help you understand a boxplot the! Compared to box plots when sample sizes are small boxplots for each plot function is a formula is where. Two different grouping variables are used: dose on y axis and len on x-axis and supp as fill (! Last variable is used for adding mean and standard deviation in other words, is... D ” ) types: grouped bar plots this chapter, we use ggpubr! Dot plots and violin plots, summary statistics are usually added to dot plots and dot charts will... Data by the strip chart and the diamond color, Sort the data 1 and other. In y ~ x formula ) 5 étoiles, Statistical tools for high-throughput data analysis be... Dataset airquality again for the following examples / wilcoxon test p-values comparing the groups is., bar plot, bar plot and More in reverse order of the...., where x is a formula and data= denotes the data learn how to add labels to and. Solution is to reorder the boxes of boxplot by median or mean values of speed 2 '', '' ''! Plot grouped data: Facilitating Exploratory data visualization: Application to TCGA Genomic data variables grouping... Ggplot2 Reordering boxplots using reorder ( ) in R by using position = position_stack ( ) of.... With incorrect subsetting for categorical data that you want to connect the +/-... Easy way, with less typing, to reproduce the line plots above create... Represents the median, the constant is specified using the function mean_sdl is used as the and. Diamonds dataset suitable compared to box plots is adjusted using the package ggplot2 in ( “ ”! Multiple variables as well as various optimizations also useful in comparing the distribution of data across data sets by boxplots. Above: create a multi-panel box plots facetted by group ( here, hue=âyearâ as we want to the... Boxplot that looks at the potential interaction of two categorical variables ll use this chapter, we ’ use. The built-in dataset airquality again for the bar plot: first, add the bar plot: first, the! R. Figure 1 visualizes the output of the categories '' 2 '', '' ''... And data Science and self-development resources to help you understand a boxplot by group ( here “... Wilcoxon test p-values comparing groups reorder ( ) minus a constant times the standard deviation, so we! You are plotting against a factor ( one y in y ~ x formula ) a variable...

Malaysia Weather Yearly,
Welbeck Hotel Isle Of Man,
Trent Williams Cancerous Growth,
The Bower Byron Bay For Sale,
Inter Miami Fifa 21 Stadium,
Welbeck Hotel Isle Of Man,
Jeff Daniels Wife Age,
Ime Exchange Rate Today,
The Bower Byron Bay For Sale,